Food

Pizza tier list

Neapolitan, New York, Chicago deep dish and 22 more pizzas to rank.

Pizza tier list
tierpanda.com

Tiles to rank 25

About this template

Pizza arguments are usually about style before toppings: thin and soft from Naples, wide New York slices, deep dish from Chicago or square Detroit pans. This template has 25 regional styles and classic pies, so you can settle the crust question first. The toppings themselves have a template of their own.

Rank them on taste, on how they hold up the next morning, or on which you would order for a crowd. Rename the rows by occasion, such as "Date night", "Game night" and "After midnight", if that suits your table better.

Rank the pizza toppings on their own, or the cheeses and the rest of Italian food.

Pizza ranked from S to F

Ranked on the pizza at its best, from a place that does that style well: the crust, the balance of sauce and cheese, and whether you'd go out of your way for it. Disagree? Drag the tiles above into your own order.

S tier

  • Neapolitan. A soft, blistered crust baked in about 90 seconds in a wood-fired oven. The original, and still the benchmark.

  • Margherita. Tomato, mozzarella and basil and nothing else, so every flaw shows. Done well, it can't be beaten.

  • New Haven apizza. Coal-fired, thin and charred at the edges. The white clam pie is one of America's great dishes.

  • New York style. Wide, thin slices you fold in half and eat walking. The best pizza for everyday life.

  • Detroit style. A thick, airy square baked in a steel pan, with cheese caramelised into a crisp edge. The style of the decade.

A tier

  • Roman al taglio. Thick, light rectangles sold by weight, with a new topping every tray. Rome's street food at its best.

  • Diavola. Spicy salami and chilli on a thin base. The best way to put heat on a pizza.

  • Pepperoni. Cups of pepperoni that crisp and hold their fat. The most popular topping in America, deservedly.

  • Sicilian. Thick, spongy and rich with sauce. Excellent from a good bakery.

  • Grandma pie. Thin, square and baked in a home oven pan, with sauce on top of the cheese. Simple and very good.

B tier

  • Marinara. Tomato, garlic, oregano and oil with no cheese. For purists, and better than it sounds.

  • Four cheese. Rich and satisfying, though the cheeses tend to blur into one.

  • Pizza bianca. No sauce at all, just dough, oil and salt. Closer to good bread than pizza.

  • Calzone. Folded and sealed, so the filling steams. Good, but you lose the crisp top.

  • Quattro stagioni. Four toppings for four seasons in four quarters. A fun idea that rarely tastes of one thing.

  • California style. Thin crusts with inventive toppings, from goat cheese to smoked salmon. Hit and miss.

  • Chicago deep dish. A tall crust with the sauce on top. Delicious, but closer to a pie, and one slice is a meal.

C tier

  • Hawaiian. Ham and pineapple, invented in Canada in 1962. Better than its critics say, worse than its fans claim.

  • BBQ chicken. Sweet sauce overwhelms the rest. A pizza for people who don't quite want pizza.

  • Paneer tikka pizza. A good idea in Indian chains, though the base usually lets the topping down.

  • Buffalo chicken. Hot sauce and ranch on dough. Better as wings.

  • Veggie supreme. Too many toppings, so the crust goes soggy in the middle.

D tier

  • Stromboli. Rolled up and sliced like a loaf. More a sandwich than a pizza.

  • Meat feast. Four meats fighting for space on one slice. Heavy rather than good.

F tier

  • St. Louis style. A cracker-thin crust under Provel, a processed cheese that never quite melts. Locals love it; few others do.

Want to rank something else?Open a blank board in the tier list maker, or sort your own tiles on an alignment chart.

New tier list

Related templates